Referred to +4dBu @ 1KHz and 40dB of gain, frequency response is -0.3dB at 20Hz and 20KHz; -3dB at <5Hz and >65KHz. Installing a 1500pF at C6 by mistake would put response down about 3dB at 5KHz. You may also have a bad op-amp.
I am so impressed that you take the time to reply to questions like this. You have convinced me to buy. I wish more company founders/presidents/CEO were like yourself. America used to be like this.