So, when I said my C84s were working, I hadn't yet tested it much on dynamic or ribbon mics, and so I hadn't noticed a hum problem that happens when the knob is above 7 or so. This problem is not in the other channels in my chassis. I checked that the power harness was wired correctly and I checked it in another room to eliminate the room environment as a factor.
When cleaning out the paint from the switch holes with a drill, I made the holes for these channels bigger than on the other channels. Could that have caused a grounding problem?