by Category 5 » Mon May 30, 2005 11:24 pm
The J99 is extremely quiet, free of distortion, has lots of gain, and has excellent bandwidth but it is not "free" of color.
It is pretty much as colored as can be without changing the source too much. That is, it is colored only enough to give a rich euphonic character to the source.
The C84 will likely be virtually devoid of ANY color. If it is like my Millennia then it will almost sound too clean compared to the other SCA preamps. This isn't a bad thing however. A lot of the time a source sounds so perfect on its own your goal is to capture JUST that sound without any change whatsoever (classical instruments such as strings come to mind, as does spanish classical guitar).
To be honest, I don;t use the Millennia much since bulding the SCA pres. I always have a sound in mind, and the SCA's are how I get it...yet I have been reluctant to get rid of the Millennia since it does come in handy when I just can't get what I'm looking for.
Maybe the C84 will take it's place and I can sell the Millennia. The HV-3 is excellent, but its' awfully expensive to have around for as much as I use it.
You might also want a completely colorless preamp when you are recording an unfamiliar source, and you want to be sure you don't commit to the wrong color.
The C84 doesn;t look all that exciting to me on paper, compared to the other designs...but that's only because I have grown so fond of transformers.
I notice the ferrite beads on the input. Doesn't teh Amek circuit claim this helps simulate transformer like sound?
Shane